Most-reviewed stay
Johnston Terrace Hostel, Old Town
Castle Rock Hostel
Hostel at 15 Johnston Terrace in Edinburgh's Old Town, with dorm beds from £16 a night.
Edinburgh has eleven hostels in this comparison, and the cheapest dorm bed anywhere in the city starts from £10 a night (see Edinburgh At Night). That price belongs to a Kick Ass Hostels property, one of two the group runs here. At the other end, a bed at the Scottish Youth Hostels Association starts from £21. Prices shown are low-season, midweek November guides for a dorm bed, and they climb steeply when the Fringe arrives.
The table ranks every hostel by price first, then by guest rating. Castle Rock Hostel leads on rating, scoring 9.42 across 25,769 reviews, with CODE Pod Hostels close behind at 9.36. Royal Mile Backpackers and the SYHA listing also score above 9. Remember each rating keeps its own platform scale, so a 9.42 on one site is not directly comparable with an 8 on another. Ratings shift as reviews accumulate.
Most-reviewed stay
Castle Rock Hostel
Hostel at 15 Johnston Terrace in Edinburgh's Old Town, with dorm beds from £16 a night.

Kick Ass Greyfriars
Hostel · Old Town
from £10 per night, dorm bedHostel at 37-39 Cowgate in Edinburgh's Old Town, with dorm beds from £10 a night.
Check availability →
Kick Ass Grassmarket
Hostel · Old Town
from £12 per night, dorm bedHostel at 2 West Port in Edinburgh's Old Town, with dorm beds from £12 a night.
Check availability →
Royal Mile Backpackers
Hostel · Old Town
from £18 per night, dorm bedHostel at 105 High Street in Edinburgh's Old Town, with dorm beds from £18 a night.
Check availability →
a&o Edinburgh City
Hostel · Old Town
from £17.52 per night, dorm bedHostel at 50 Blackfriars Street in Edinburgh's Old Town, with dorm beds from £17.52 a night.
Check availability →
Argyle Backpackers
Hostel · Southside and Newington
from £20 per night, dorm bedHostel at 14 Argyle Place in Edinburgh's Southside and Newington, with dorm beds from £20 a night.
Check availability →
High Street Hostel
Hostel · Old Town
from £19 per night, dorm bedHostel at 8 Blackfriars St in Edinburgh's Old Town, with dorm beds from £19 a night.
Check availability →
Princes Street Hostel
Hostel · New Town
from £18 per night, dorm bedHostel at 5 West Register Street in Edinburgh's New Town, with dorm beds from £18 a night.
Check availability →
CODE - The Court
Hostel · Old Town
from £19.53 per night, dorm bedHostel at 1A Parliament Square in Edinburgh's Old Town, with dorm beds from £19.53 a night.
Check availability →
St Christopher's Edinburgh - Old Town
Hostel · Old Town
from £15.43 per night, dorm bedHostel at 32 Market Street in Edinburgh's Old Town, with dorm beds from £15.43 a night.
Check availability →
Edinburgh Central Youth Hostel
Hostel · New Town
from £21.42 per night, dorm bedHostel at 9 Haddington Place in Edinburgh's New Town, with dorm beds from £21.42 a night.
Check availability →Price is the obvious filter, but location matters just as much in a city this walkable. Hostels on or near the Royal Mile, such as Castle Rock, Royal Mile Backpackers and High Street Hostel, put most of the Old Town within a short walk. St Christopher's Inns and the a&o property sit slightly further out, which usually shows in the bed price. Decide whether you want to be beside the nightlife or a few stops from it.
Rating gaps tell you something too. The a&o and Argyle Backpackers listings sit in the mid-7s, while CODE Pod Hostels and Princes Street Hostel clear 8.5. Those differences often reflect noise, dorm size and the state of shared bathrooms rather than safety or staff. Larger chains such as a&o trade polish for scale, with 3,069 reviews behind their score. Smaller hostels, like Argyle with 2,637 reviews, can feel more sociable in the kitchen.
Hostel beds from £10 a night fill first once August approaches, because Fringe performers grab dorms early, and official Fringe Society advice confirms affordable options go first-come, first-served. Book January or February stays for the lowest rates of the year, well under the summer peak. For the Fringe itself, commit by spring. Outside the centre, Southside beds sit minutes from venues at gentler prices.